Skip to main site content.
Comedian Bill Cosby is helped from a courtroom at the Montgomery County Courthouse in Norristown, Pennsylvania, on July 7, 2016 after Judge Steven O'Neill ruled against Cosby's lawyers and did not throw the criminal case out. ( MICHAEL BRYANT/AFP/Getty Images)


Judge shoots down Cosby’s latest bid to have criminal sex assault charges tossed

By WITW Staff on July 8, 2016

Disgraced comedy legend Bill Cosby was dealt a legal blow on Thursday when a Pennsylvania judge ruled there was enough evidence to proceed with a criminal trial. Judge Steven O’Neill denied Cosby’s lawyers’ request to dismiss the charges on the grounds that they were never given the chance to cross-examine Andrea Constand, Cosby’s accuser in this case, during the preliminary hearing in May. Instead of Constand appearing in court at the time, prosecutors presented evidence from a police statement given by Constand a decade after the alleged crime. Cosby’s lawyers argued that Constand’s statement to police is hearsay and raised more legal questions that it answered. But the judge didn’t buy that line of reasoning, and ruled the trial will go forward. “It’s our position that we’re not going to re-traumatize victims,” he said about the decision.

Cosby sat silently in court watching the proceedings unfold. Afterward, prosecutors lauded O’Neill’s ruling and Cosby’s lawyers criticized it. Brian McMonagle, the 78-year-old comedian’s lead attorney, vowed to clear Cosby’s “good name.”

Read the full story at USA Today.


Bill Cosby accuser described feeling panicked and ‘dizzy’ in encounter as judge rules Cosby will go to trial

Video of Cosby interviewing Sofia Vergara in 2003 resurfaces, makes people squirm

Why did Bill Cosby want to have sex with comatose women?